| |
BANGLADESH & ARSENIC |
|
|
| |
|
General
information |
| |
|
The people's Republic of Bangladesh occupies a territory in the
north-eastern part of the Indian subcontinent above the Bay of Bengal
between 200.34'- 260.38' N latitude and 880.01'-920.41' E longitude. It has a
territory of 147,570 sq. km and a population of 130 million. Population
growth rate is 2.1 annum. Density of population 800 per sq.km; sex ratio:
106 male to 100 female. Literacy rate was 32.4% in 1991 but now it is
about 47%. There are 88.3% Muslims, 10.5% Hindus, 0.6% Buddhists and 0.3%
Christians and others 0.1% . The urban population constitutes 20.1%
and rural population 79.9%. The state language is Bengali, but English is
widely used and understood.
|
|
Administrative set up |
| |
|
Bangladesh has a parliamentary form of government with the prime
Minister as the chief executive. The country is divided into 6
administrative divisions. Each division is subdivided into Zilas, which in
their turn consists of thanas. Thanas are then divided into unions
consisting of several Mouzas (revenue villages). At present there are 64
districts and 496 thanas. There are 19.4 million households distributed
over 59.990 Mouzas.
|
|
Climate |
| |
|
Bangladesh enjoys sub-tropical climate with the average temperature
ranging in summer between 21-34 degrees C and in winter between
11-29degrees Average rainfall: 1194- 3454 mm: highest humidity in July –
99% and lowest in December 31%.
|
|
Brief political history |
|
|
|
Bangladesh has emerged as an independent state after a 9-month long
bloody liberation war in 1971. Before that time it was a province of
Pakistan and was called East Pakistan. Going further back this land was a
part of the provinces of Bengal and Assam of the British colony of India.
As a result of the anti-colonial struggle of the people of India the
British had to quit India in 1947 and while doing so they divided the
subcontinent into two separate states, namely India and Pakistan on
religious ground.
|
|
Brief geological outline
|
| |
|
Bangladesh occupies the major portion of the Bengal
basin. Nearly 85% of the recent sediments of Bangladesh have been
deposited by alluvial and deltaic processes of the mighty rivers like the
Ganges, the Brahmaputra, the Meghna and the Teesta. Many other smaller
rivers also have their contributions, but to a lesser extent. There are
about 230 rivers with a total length of about 24, 140 km. The active delta
occupies the area south of the Ganges river and mostly west of the Meghna
estuary. Most of the delta is less than 15 m above the sea level and the
tidal zone is generally 3 m above that level. There are some hilly regions
in the north-east and the south-east and some high lands in the north and
north-western part of the country.
Composition of sediments depends on the rocks of their
origin. Those associated with the river Ganges tend to be rich in clay and
often contain silts, rather than clay.
Total forest area covers about 14% of the land area.
Mineral resources include natural gas, coal, limestone,
hard rock, lignite, silica sand, which clay etc. Radioactive sand deposits
have been found along the beaches.
|
|
Health status
|
| |
|
According to 1995 statistic, crude birth rate is
27, crude death rate 8.6, infant mortality rate 78 and life expectancy at
birth 58. Predominant diseases/symptoms are acid secretion, heartburn,
dyspepsia, gastritis, peptic ulcer (10. 16%), diarrhoea (10.84%), cold
(6.7%) fever (11.55%), scabies, abscess (3.63%), rheumatism (3.28%),
malaria (3.28%), asthma (2.54%), influenza (3.07%), blood pressure (1.67%)
typhoid (1.56%), measles (0.96), tuberculosis (0.53%), and others.
|
|
Water habit
|
| |
|
97% of the population of Bangladesh use tube-well water
for drinking and cooking purposes. The rural people use pond, lake and
river water for washing, bathing and other domestic purposes. The urban
people use deep tube-well water for the same. For irrigation river and
deep tube-well waters are used.
According to DPHE source, in 1993-94 there were 855,
996 hand/shallow tube-wells in rural areas and the number of deep
tube-wells in 8 former coastal of Chittagong, Noakhali, Sylhet, Khulna,
Barishal, Faridpur, Patuakhali and Jessore was 51,819.
|
|
Genesis of the arsenic
problem
|
| |
|
Until recently the arsenic problem was almost unknown
in Bangladesh, although in neighboring West Bengal it became evident in
the mid-eighties. Arsenic specialists in Calcutta however, predicted that
as the younger deltaic deposition stretched from West Bengal into
Bangladesh, the latter might also have arsenic contamination of ground
water. The prediction held true as they found patients from the bordering
districts of Bangladesh with arsenical skin lesion going to Calcutta for
treatment. They warned the government of Bangladesh and the WHO about the
presence of arsenicosis patients in Bangladesh in the early nineties and
accordingly Bangladesh government began some investigations in this
direction, however it was kept more or less unpronounced and neither the
physician community, nor the public knew anything about it until 1996 when
Dhaka Community Hospital came into the scene.
In June 1996, Dhaka Community Hospital held a health
camp at Pakshi in the western part of the country in which several skin
patients were suspected of having arsenical skin lesions. Tube-well from
that area was tested and was found to have high content of arsenic. DCH
informed the local officials and made newspaper reports. Following this
news on arsenic began flowing from other districts, There were rumor and
tales, however nobody seemed to be knowing how real the arsenic threat
was. DCH felt the need to respond to the interest of the public health and
send a fact finding team consisting of 8 members including 3 skin
specialists and 3 other senior doctors to that area. They collected water
samples from 41 tube-wells and biological samples (nail, hair, skin and
urine) form 95 patients. Water samples were tested at the BCSIR
Laboratories, Dhaka, while biological samples were tested at the School of
Environmental Studies, Jadavpur University, Calcutta 66% of the water
samples and more than 90% of the biological samples water found to have
higher than normal concentration of arsenic. DCH made the results public
in a national seminar held with the participation of Dr. Dipankar
Chakraborty of the SOES, Jadavpur University, Calcutta in January 1997 and
urged the government and other concerned organizations to take immediate
steps to face the problem.
|
|
Extent of the problem
|
| |
|
At present several departments
of the government with assistance from international donor
agencies, some NGOs, university departments and private
organizations are working on the arsenic problem and
although there is lack of standardization in their work
(for example, some are using laboratory methods, others
are using kits for testing water) and exchange of
information among themselves, an overall gloomy picture
has emerged. Judging from the scattered reports publish to
the press from time to time many organizations have found
unacceptable level of arsenic in ground water form a vast
majority of the districts of the country and a large
number of patients suffering and dying from arsenicosis and its complications. To present a systematic view and
statistically sound conception of the extent of the arsenic problem in
Bangladesh, we below use data collected by Dhaka Community Hospital in
collaboration with School of Environmental studies, Jadavpur University,
Calcutta.
|
|
In terms of underground
water |
| |
|
To date 30,000 tube-wells from 64 districts have been
tested for the presence of arsenic in underground water by the
above-mentioned organizations. In 47 districts water samples were found to
have arsenic above 0.05mg/1, the maximum permissible limit, recommended by
WHO and in 54 districts the arsenic concentration was more than 0.01 mg/1,
the WHO recommended value for safe water. In those 47 districts where
arsenic concentration crossed 0.05 mg/1 limit, 54.64% of the samples were
found to have crossed that border. Area of these 47 districts is 47,732,
sq. km with a population of 76.9 million. At the present state of
knowledge it can be safely concluded that although not all tube-wells are
contaminated, there are thousands of pockets of contaminated underground
water in at least two thirds of the districts of Bangladesh and the people
living there are at real risk of developing arsenic toxicosis.
|
|
In terms of patients
|
| |
|
DCH and SOES conducted surveys for arsenicosis patients
in 64 districts and found patients with arsenical skin lesions in 32 of
them. They examined 24664 people in the affected villages and 33.6% of
them were diagnosed as patients with arsenical akin manifestations. A
Total of 2167 hair samples, 2165 nail samples, 220 skin samples and 830
urine samples were analyzed and an average of 94% of them were found to
have arsenic concentration above the normal limit. A report form the
National Institute of Preventive and Social Medicine stated that they had
more than 800 arsenicosis patients in their list. At the skin department
of IPGM & R 250 patients with arsenical skin lesions have been
investigated and treated. It is obvious that if systematic surveys are
conducted in all the districts where there is high level of arsenic in
underground water, more patients will be found. So at this moment it can
be safely concluded that there are thousands of arsenicosis patients in
Bangladesh.
|
|
Causes of arsenic
contamination
|
|
|
|
Earlier several hypotheses
were put forward including one that the arsenic compound treated rural
electrification poles were the source of arsenic contamination of
underground water and the other that insecticides and fertilizers were the
culprit, but these did not found to hold water. Now it has been more or
less generally agreed upon that the source of arsenic contamination is
geological with mobilization of arsenic due some Geochemical processes.
|
|
Efforts in mitigation of
arsenic disaster
|
|
|
|
Since 1996 different organizations including the
government, NGOs and private organizations have come forward to study
different aspects of the arsenic problem and find out ways of combating
against it, however these are still in very initial stage. The government
has formed a National Steering Committee with the minister of health and
family planning as its chairman. Other government bodies involved in the
arsenic work are: Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and
Co-operatives (MoLGRDC), Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoH&FP),
Economic Relations Division of the Ministry of Finance, Planning
Commission, Environmental and Geographic Information System for water
Resources Planning (EGIS), National Institute of Preventive, Social and
Occupational Medicine, Department of Public Health Engineering (DPHE),
Institute of Postgraduate Medicine and Research (IPGM&R).
International donor agencies have shown their interest
in the arsenic problem. At least 3 arsenic teams of the World Bank have
visited Bangladesh by December 1997. The UNDP has funded a Rapid Action
Program (RAP) which is currently being implemented jointly by the Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare and Dhaka Community Hospital in 200 villages
of the arsenic affected districts. In 3 months time the program is to
assess the gravity of the situation if the villages, seek community based
solutions to the problem and put forward recommendations for further
programs to be drawn. The UNICEF has provided field test kits to DPHE and
other organizations and is considering elaborate programs. WHO invited
arsenic experts to this country and held a meeting in New Delhi on the
arsenic problem in Bangladesh. Foreign missions like the British High
Commission/DFID, the Embassies of Japan/JICA, Denmark/DANIDA, Canada/CIDA
and the Netherlands have shown their willingness to take part in the fight
against arsenic. Asia Arsenic Network is actually running a project in
Samta, a remote village in the western part of the country.
Some NGOs are actively involved in efforts to solve the
arsenic problem. The Disaster Forum, an association of NGO’s working in
disaster management was once very active in organizing arsenic activities,
but now it seems to have lost its tempo. Perhaps without the initial
support of the Disaster Forum, the arsenic situation would not have taken
the shape it has today. Some other NGO’s deserve mentioning like ADAB,
NGO Forum, BRAC, Grameen Bank etc.
As a private organization Dhaka Community Hospital has
been involved in the alleviation of the arsenic problem form the very
beginning. It has conducted extensive surveys, sampling, supportive
treatment of patients, training programs for doctors and other health and
community workers and awareness program. When at the beginning it was
being said that the arsenic problem was not that serious and being
exaggerated, DCH held a national seminar in January 1996 and proved that
it was a real threat to our public health. Currently DCH is engaged in
implementing the Rapid Action program in collaboration with the Ministry
of Health and Family Welfare. It has organized the International seminar
in collaboration with SOES.
School of Environmental Studies, Jadavpur University,
Calcutta, West Bengal, India (SOES) has been the pioneer organization in
ringing alarms for arsenic calamity in Bangladesh. Actually it is in the
laboratory of this school that most of the water samples and almost all
the biological samples from Bangladesh have been tested for arsenic. Its
director Dr. Dipankar Chakraborty has extensively traveled over vast
region of the country over and over again meeting with peoples in their
doorstep, collecting samples and supporting and soothing patients and
relatives. He has direct consultative links with almost all the
organizations in this country who are working on arsenic. His role in
raising the arsenic awareness in this country is enormous.
Other organizations that deserve to be mentioned
include Atomic Energy Commission and BCSIR Laboratories who have some
facilities for water testing, although very costly for the common people;
ICDDR,B which is experimenting with removal of arsenic from contaminated
water; geological departments of Rajshahi and Dhaka Universities,
chemistry department of Jahangirnagar University and BUET who are doing
some work in their respective fields.
|
|
Conclusion
|
|
|
|
There is no doubt that the
arsenic situation in Bangladesh is very grave to say the least. Patients
are suffering, relatives are desperate and physicians are at a loss. Still
we are optimistic that with joint efforts of the government, national
organizations, international agencies and scientific community some
solution will be reached that will bring smile to faces of the distressed.
To mobilize and organize efforts of the international community toward
that goal is the prime target of this seminar. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|